• A devastating fire destroyed Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein’s Edisto Beach home Saturday, hospitalizing three family members.
• Former state senator Arnold Goodstein and his son escaped by jumping from windows as flames engulfed the property.
• State investigators are probing the blaze after sources reported the judge had recently received death threats.

Flames and Rescue Operations

The fire erupted around 11:30 a.m. on Saturday at the Goodsteins’ beachfront property in the Jeremy Cay Community on Edisto Beach. Judge Goodstein was walking her dog when the blaze began, but her husband and son were inside and had to jump from windows to escape the intense flames. The home’s location near marshy terrain made rescue efforts particularly challenging, prompting several neighbors to assist paramedics using a canoe and rope to pull victims to safety.

Tom Peterson, a neighbor who witnessed the fire, described the dramatic scene to local media. Three people were ultimately hospitalized, with one requiring air evacuation to the Medical University of South Carolina. The extent of their injuries has not been publicly disclosed.

Investigation Underway

The South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) responded to the scene and confirmed it is conducting an active investigation into the cause of the fire. The agency has not publicly stated whether it suspects arson, though the circumstances have drawn significant attention from investigators.

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10

The South Carolina Supreme Court acknowledged the incident in a statement, with Chief Justice John W. Kittredge confirming he was aware of the situation involving Judge Goodstein. The home, a four-bedroom, three-story structure overlooking the marsh, was completely destroyed.

Controversial Context

Judge Goodstein, 69, has served as a circuit court judge since 1998 and has been involved in numerous high-profile cases throughout her career. Most recently, she temporarily blocked South Carolina’s election commission from releasing voter files to the Department of Justice, a decision that drew criticism from federal officials before being reversed by the state Supreme Court.

Multiple sources told local news outlet FITSNews that the judge had received death threats in the weeks leading up to the fire. However, law enforcement has not confirmed this information or connected any threats to the incident. The timing has sparked conversations about judicial security nationwide, as judges increasingly face threats for their rulings.

The Goodstein Family Legacy

Judge Diane Goodstein has built a distinguished legal career spanning nearly three decades on the bench. Her husband, Arnold Goodstein, served as a state senator and was once a prominent home builder who led Summerville Homes before the company ceased operations in 2008. The couple’s deep roots in South Carolina politics and law have made them well-known figures throughout the state.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM THE THE DUPREE REPORT

The Jeremy Cay neighborhood where the fire occurred is typically quiet and peaceful, making the dramatic incident all the more shocking to residents. Property records confirm the couple owned the destroyed home, which overlooked the scenic marshlands connecting Edisto Beach to Edisto Island.

Moving Forward

As investigators continue their work, the cause of the fire remains officially undetermined. SLED has urged anyone with information, photos, or videos from the area on Saturday morning to come forward. The investigation is ongoing, and officials have indicated more information may be released as their work progresses.

The incident has left the Goodstein family dealing with not only the loss of their home but also the trauma of the injuries sustained during the escape. The legal and political communities across South Carolina have expressed support for the family during this difficult time. This fire comes amid a broader pattern of threats against public officials, including an April arson attack on Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro’s residence that left millions in damage.

What measures should be in place to protect judges and their families from potential threats?

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10