• Candace Owens alleged TPUSA “scammed its views by paying platform advertisers” for its All-American Halftime Show
• TPUSA producer Blake Neff claimed over 5 million concurrent YouTube viewers, but Owens pointed to a screenshot showing under 6,000
• The accusation deepens an internal conservative feud between Owens and TPUSA CEO Erika Kirk that has simmered since Charlie Kirk’s September 2025 assassination

PHOENIX, AZ (TDR) — Political commentator Candace Owens accused Turning Point USA of artificially inflating viewership numbers for its All-American Halftime Show, escalating a months-long internal conservative conflict that has fractured one of the right’s most prominent organizations. Hours after the show streamed opposite Bad Bunny’s Super Bowl LX halftime performance on Feb. 8, Owens took to X and alleged TPUSA had manufactured its audience.

Owens Claims Paid View Inflation

Owens, 36, responded to an X post that captured a YouTube account’s viewer count at just under 6,000 — a figure dramatically lower than what TPUSA officials were publicly claiming at the time.

“The problem with people who have a lot of money they didn’t earn, is that they tend to have no idea how stuff actually works.”

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10

In a follow-up post, the former TPUSA communications director made her accusation explicit.

“We have an organization that scammed its views by paying platform advertisers, followed by influencers to pretend they broke records.”

The allegation directly contradicted numbers posted by Blake Neff, a producer for The Charlie Kirk Show who helped stage the halftime production. Neff’s breakdown on X claimed substantial concurrent viewership across multiple platforms.

“TPUSA All-American Halftime Show … Over 5 million simultaneous on TPUSA YT. Almost 1 million on Charlie Kirk’s YT. 200k on Magno News YT. 220k on TPUSA Rumble. 15k CK Rumble. The entire audience on RAV. And noticeably, the audience kept going up throughout the competing show.”

The Numbers in Dispute

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM THE THE DUPREE REPORT

Independent observers offered mixed assessments of the viewership claims. Ryan Glasspiegel of Front Office Sports estimated the show peaked at roughly 6 million views across two YouTube feeds, though he noted the lip-syncing concerns with Kid Rock’s performance. The Athletic reported a peak of 6.1 million concurrent viewers on TPUSA’s YouTube channel alone.

TPUSA spokesman Andrew Kolvet went further, telling Fox News host Brian Kilmeade the number “could rise to 50 million” — a projection that drew skepticism given that the YouTube stream showed approximately 19 million total views by Monday morning, a figure that includes replays and is not comparable to concurrent viewership.

Digital media experts note that YouTube’s live concurrent viewer count is publicly visible during streams, making large-scale fabrication difficult but not impossible. View manipulation techniques range from bot networks using rotating IP addresses to paid click farms that simulate real user behavior. YouTube’s detection systems now identify fake traffic with what one industry analysis estimated at over 96% accuracy, though sophisticated operations can still evade filters temporarily.

Owens did not specify what evidence she had for the paid-view allegation beyond the screenshot showing a low viewer count on one account. The discrepancy could reflect a smaller affiliate channel rather than TPUSA’s primary stream, though this distinction was not addressed in her posts.

A Feud With Deep Roots

The viewership accusation represents the latest chapter in an escalating conflict between Owens and TPUSA that began after founder Charlie Kirk was assassinated on Sept. 10, 2025, at Utah Valley University. Tyler Robinson, 22, was arrested and charged with aggravated murder, but Owens has publicly questioned whether Robinson acted alone.

On her podcast, Owens has promoted unsubstantiated theories about Kirk’s death, at one point speculating it involved a military operation and implying Israeli involvement. When pressed by Piers Morgan on whether TPUSA staff had foreknowledge, Owens conceded she lacked “concrete evidence” for naming specific individuals.

The tension between Owens and Erika Kirk, who assumed the CEO role after her husband’s death, has played out across leaked recordings, fired employees and public accusations. In late January, Owens published a leaked Zoom call recorded roughly 12 days after Kirk’s assassination in which Erika appeared to be discussing organizational metrics with staff.

“We are not even two weeks after watching your husband be assassinated. We’re talking about numbers and metrics that have been hit.”

Earlier in February, Owens shared a video from Aubrey Laitsch, a former TPUSA public relations manager who alleged she was terminated after an executive heard secondhand criticism of Erika Kirk’s leadership. Laitsch claimed staff were “regularly working 20-hour days with no extra compensation” following the assassination and described an environment where “freedom of speech is no longer accepted.”

Owens has also alleged that TPUSA raised approximately $250 million in the months following Kirk’s death while simultaneously sending cease-and-desist letters to YouTubers who questioned the official investigation narrative.

TPUSA has not responded to requests for comment on the viewership allegations. The organization did not respond to prior requests from multiple outlets regarding the employee termination claims.

Neither Show Earned Owens’ Approval

Notably, Owens rejected both halftime offerings on Super Bowl Sunday.

“I am sorry but I hate both options.”

Of Bad Bunny’s official NFL performance — which featured surprise appearances from Lady Gaga and Ricky Martin and is expected to draw over 120 million viewers — Owens wrote that it was “a halftime show presented without a word of English spoken.”

She concluded with a broader critique that appeared aimed at both political camps.

“The left vs. right grift is actually boring now. What exactly are we doing here, America?”

The comment placed Owens in unusual alignment with neither the conservative movement that celebrated the TPUSA production nor progressive voices who praised Bad Bunny’s cultural celebration and unity message. President Donald Trump called Bad Bunny’s performance “absolutely terrible, one of the worst, EVER” on Truth Social but has not publicly commented on the TPUSA show.

What Independent Verification Shows

The viewership dispute highlights a broader challenge with self-reported digital metrics in an era of platform-based counterprogramming. YouTube’s public concurrent viewer counter was the primary source for all reported numbers — TPUSA’s claims, media reports and Owens’ counter-screenshot alike. No independent third-party auditor such as Nielsen has released verified figures for the TPUSA stream.

By contrast, the official Super Bowl broadcast is measured by Nielsen, which reported 133.5 million viewers for Kendrick Lamar’s 2025 halftime performance. Official 2026 figures have not yet been released.

What is verifiable: TPUSA’s YouTube stream showed approximately 19 million total views by Monday morning. Kolvet confirmed the organization plans to host another halftime show in 2027. And the conservative movement’s most visible internal critic has now added viewership fraud to her growing list of allegations against the organization her former ally built.

When political organizations self-report audience metrics without independent verification, should supporters and critics alike demand third-party auditing — and would either side accept the results?

Sources

This report was compiled using information from US Magazine’s reporting on Owens’ viewership claims, Front Office Sports’ analysis of TPUSA viewership, Newsweek’s coverage of TPUSA viewership claims and 2027 plans, The Athletic’s concurrent viewer reporting, Barrett Media’s platform breakdown, KATV’s reporting on the Owens-Kirk leaked recording and fired TPUSA employee video, Britannica’s profile on Owens’ TPUSA history, Sportskeeda’s coverage of the $250 million fundraising allegation, The Hill’s reporting on the Owens-TPUSA feud, and Gridiron Heroics’ coverage of Owens’ Piers Morgan interview.

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10