• The Phoenix Suns face multiple lawsuits accusing the organization of workplace dysfunction, racial discrimination, security failures, and a sexual misconduct scandal involving CEO Josh Bartelstein and former Mercury star Sophie Cunningham.
• Allegations include racial bias, retaliation, and negligence, with former security director Gene Traylor and others claiming systemic issues persist under Mat Ishbia’s leadership.
• The Suns deny all accusations, calling them false and orchestrated, while critics argue the franchise has yet to fully move on from the toxic culture of the Robert Sarver era.

The Phoenix Suns, once heralded as entering a “new era” after their record-breaking $4 billion acquisition by Mat Ishbia in 2022, now face a torrent of lawsuits accusing the organization of workplace dysfunction, racial discrimination, security failures, and a shocking sexual scandal. These allegations, detailed in four federal lawsuits, threaten to unravel the franchise’s reputation and challenge its leadership’s efforts to distance itself from the disgraced Robert Sarver era.

Sexual Scandal at the Center of Allegations

In the most recent lawsuit, former Suns security director Gene Traylor accuses Suns CEO Josh Bartelstein of engaging in an improper sexual relationship with former Phoenix Mercury star Sophie Cunningham. According to court filings, this claim stems from a conversation where Suns executive Dan Craig allegedly told others about the relationship. Traylor quoted the statement explicitly: “Josh Bartelstein is f**ing Sophie Cunningham.”*

Neither Bartelstein nor Cunningham has commented publicly, but the accusation raises serious concerns about conflict of interest and ethical violations, as both the Suns and Mercury are under the same Ishbia-led ownership. The fallout could further strain the franchise’s efforts to project a culture of reform and transparency.

Racial Discrimination and Retaliation Claims

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10

Traylor’s lawsuit goes beyond the sex scandal. He also alleges that his demotion stemmed from racial discrimination, describing himself as “an educated, accomplished Black professional” whose credentials made Suns leadership uncomfortable. He cites the organization’s failure to address security risks, claiming that undercover Homeland Defense field tests exposed vulnerabilities like concealed weapons bypassing arena checks. Despite repeated warnings, Traylor says leaders ignored his concerns before retaliating against him.

This issue isn’t new for the Suns. In November 2024, the team’s former head of diversity, equity, and inclusion filed a lawsuit alleging that little had improved since Sarver’s suspension for racist, sexist, and abusive behavior. These lawsuits reveal what attorney Sheree D. Wright calls a “toxic through line” of systemic issues across departments and roles.

Other Pending Lawsuits Against the Suns

Traylor’s case joins three additional lawsuits filed in 2024. Each levels serious accusations of a hostile work environment, retaliation, and discrimination:

• In April, a Hispanic female employee (identified as Jane Doe) alleged retaliation and workplace discrimination.
• In March, a 46-year-old video engineer claimed he was demoted to contractor status and forced to work in unsafe, unsanitary conditions.
• The November 2024 lawsuit from the diversity head underscored pervasive issues that leadership failed to address.

Wright, representing all four plaintiffs, said the lawsuits collectively underscore a culture of “racial discrimination, retaliation, and systemic failures in accountability.”

The Suns Push Back on Allegations

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM THE THE DUPREE REPORT

The Suns have strongly denied all claims, labeling them “delusional and categorically false.” Stacey Mitch, senior vice president of communications, accused Wright of attempting to “extort” the organization and vowed that the Suns would hold her accountable. Mitch emphasized that the team remains committed to the reforms introduced under Mat Ishbia’s leadership, framing the lawsuits as an orchestrated attack against the franchise.

To discredit Wright, the Suns highlighted her probation with the State Bar of Arizona, citing past issues like missed filing deadlines. Wright fired back, asserting that these personal attacks aim to deflect from the organization’s misconduct.

What This Means for the Suns’ Reputation

Under Mat Ishbia, the Suns were expected to leave behind the controversies of the Sarver era. However, the explosive lawsuits and the recent sex scandal paint a starkly different picture. Allegations of racial bias, security negligence, and a lack of accountability are eroding the franchise’s efforts to position itself as a reformed organization.

Fans and analysts alike question whether the team has truly moved forward. While Mitch insists Ishbia’s leadership has brought about positive change, the growing number of lawsuits tells a different story. For employees within the organization, the promises of reform seem far removed from their lived experiences.

Key Takeaways

• Josh Bartelstein and Sophie Cunningham are at the center of a sexual misconduct accusation that raises ethical concerns.
• Multiple lawsuits accuse the Suns of racial discrimination, retaliation, and fostering a hostile workplace.
• Gene Traylor cites security negligence, claiming the leadership ignored warnings about glaring safety risks.
• The organization vigorously denies the allegations, portraying attorney Sheree D. Wright as leading a smear campaign.

What’s Next for the Suns?

As the lawsuits pile up, the Suns face growing pressure to address the systemic issues alleged by current and former employees. If Wright’s prediction holds true, more lawsuits may surface, further challenging the narrative of reform under Mat Ishbia. How the franchise handles these crises will determine whether it can regain trust and stability—or if the current leadership will face the same scrutiny that ended Sarver’s tenure.

What do you think about these allegations and their impact on the Suns? Share your thoughts in the comments below and spread the word by sharing this article!

Freedom-Loving Beachwear by Red Beach Nation - Save 10% With Code RVM10